How Botanical Products Are Labeled

Posted by

The world of wellness products is a legal grey area. They tend to bring on more questions than answers. Not all are dietary supplements, so they can’t – or at least, shouldn’t – be labeled as such. This is where botanicals come in. 

Curious minds want to know: Where and how do they fit in? What are the regulations surrounding their labeling? Should they have multiple categories or a different one entirely? If they’re unregulated, why is the FDA involved?

If you’ve been wondering how they’re marketed for public retail sale, you’re not alone. Learn about the complexities around botanicals and the nuances involved in their labelling. 

Classification Under Federal Law

Many wellness products are often known as dietary supplements or dietary ingredients. These provide nutrients, such as vitamins or minerals, or bioactive compounds. Nootropics, also known as “smart drugs,” might be synthetic, but more often than not are naturally derived or concentrated extracts from herbs, roots, and plants. Since they have been recognized in the medical world, they have the FDA classification of Pharmacologic Class. 

You might see certain wellness products or dietary supplements also classified as food. Wellness tonics and other botanicals can fall into the category of “food” if they are edible in the form of a beverage or a snack. 

Botanicals that are ingested but are not food cannot be classed as drugs – medical drugs – since they are not recognized to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease or condition. So, products including kratom, 7-OH, 7-OH alternatives, and mushrooms would fit here.

Controlled Substances or Not?

Let’s focus more on botanicals like kratom, 7-OH, Oxonol, Pseudo, and mushrooms, since they come under fire a lot for the lack of mandatory regulation in the industry as a general rule. At the federal level, they are legal. This just means the nation as a whole allows it, especially by way of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) as a regulatory body and an authoritative organization.

Illegal But Not a Controlled Substance: How and Why?

On the other hand, there are the individual states to consider. What’s legal in one state could be illegal in another, and what’s fine in a state could be banned in certain areas. There are usually one of two classifications a state or municipality applies to the botanical product in question:

  • A Class I scheduled drug, meaning a substance with the highest risk of tolerance, physical dependency, withdrawal symptoms, and abuse, as well as no documented or recognized medical benefits; or
  • Chemically similar to a drug that’s illegal or classed as a Schedule I controlled substance according to the Federal Analogue Act

For comparison, medical analgesics like morphine and fentanyl, and opioids available by prescription are usually Class II scheduled drugs, since they have known medical uses. They are stronger than Class III, which likewise have medical uses but less potential of tolerance, physical dependency, and abuse. 

Controversy Over FDA Classification

The terms that customers often see on botanical products tend to include either of the following:

  • Herbal supplement or specimen
  • Wellness tonic
  • Adaptogen formula
  • Proprietary formula
  • Botanical or product
  • Wellness lifestyle product

These are somewhat vague and aren’t clearly implying anything about the product’s legal status or intended use. Here’s where the FDA comes in to have labeling requirements depending on the product’s category. 

FDA Categories

Products fall into either of the following categories:

  • Foods: Products that may include some wellness tonics and other botanicals, as long as they are edible in the form of a snack or beverage. Must include a Supplement Facts section. Any health claims must relate to structure and function if not FDA-approved. 
  • Dietary supplements or dietary ingredients: Products intended to supplement the diet, whether through vitamins, minerals, amino acids, herbs, botanicals, or other dietary ingredients that may be natural or synthetic. May include health claims, but must have a disclaimer stating it is not intended to diagnose, cure, treat, or prevent any disease. 
  • Botanicals or new dietary ingredients: Products that don’t qualify as dietary supplements or dietary ingredients, but may or may not also be food. Kratom, 7-OH, and mushrooms all fall into this category. Novel or synthetic molecules or rare plant isolates that weren’t present in the food supply before 1994 fit here. 
  • Drugs: Medical products that claim to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent disease. Require FDA approval, clinical trials for efficacy and safety, and detailed labeling. 

Why Some Wellness Products Are Not Dietary Supplements

To make it a bit more confusing, some botanicals contain a formula that includes dietary ingredients. So, you can have a botanical that’s also a food, like chocolate amanita mushrooms or kratom beverages. You can also have a botanical that has at least one dietary ingredient, like kratom and kava shots (kava is a recognized nootropic). 

The main takeaway that sets botanicals apart from dietary supplements is the presence of novel or synthetic compounds or even natural bioactive compounds that don’t provide things the body lacks, nor has any widely agreed health benefits. Kratom is from a plant but is a botanical or new dietary ingredient rather than a dietary supplement for this very reason. 

Botanicals with Transparent Labeling

Wellness lifestyle products, also known as botanicals, occupy a complex space somewhere between foods and drugs. Although many seem to qualify as dietary supplements, they come in concentrated forms that go beyond traditional consumption or have novel ingredients that simply haven’t undergone enough research to investigate possible therapeutic benefits. This dilemma makes it confusing to tell whether certain products are properly labeled for the consumer’s information according to how they’re used. 

Getting the safest botanicals is possible if you know what to look for, though. Transparent ingredients, independent, third-party label testing, and strict quality control that follows manufacturing standards similar to those in food, drug, and supplement industries are all important. One vendor that has all of that and is even manufacturer-direct is Real Botanicals. They have no middlemen, so there’s no confusion, and you come away informed. 

See also: “The Federal Analogue Act and What That Means for You“

“Dealing with Legal Restrictions on Kratom, 7-OH, and Mushrooms“

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *